Skip to content

Peeps Party Cake and Cookies

    Peeps and Company generously provided the Peeps and the Gift Basket. All opinions are my own.
    I’m hoping everyone in the world saw my Peeps Bubble Gum Ice Cream! If you didn’t you can just click on the little link there…
    Today, I’ve got fun cake and cookies. I had a fun time making this cake with the pink and yellow decorations and the fun summer combination of the Lemonade and Bubble Gum as just perfect!

    My daughter loved the look of this cake! She thought it was quite hilarious that I put the Peeps on the cookie and then stood them up on top of the cake! She like the lollipop idea of them but had never seen lollipops sticking out of a cake like that. 
    I’ll take that as a nice compliment.
    She also enjoyed the pink and yellow swirls that I did with the frosting. It kinda looked like pretty flowers. 
    We really enjoyed these sweet desserts!

    Peeps was also kind enough to send me my choice of one of their new Gift Baskets to review. As you can see, Peeps aren’t just for Easter for anymore
    Peeps and Company has an assortment of Gift Baskets that are great for just about any occasion!
    They have the following available:
    I choose the Get Well Basket to give to my neighbor. 

    My neighbor is a mother of three and a special education teacher. Just as school was ending in June she went to the doctor with a very bad headache. She was told that she had a sinus infection and was sent home. Later that night, the headache was still pounding but her speech became slurred, the color in her face turn grey and in the middle of the night she was medevaced from her home to John Hopkins in Baltimore where she underwent brain surgery. 
    Of course, it was a total shock to the family and they were left wondering what was going to happen. Fast forward three months and she is doing great! She doesn’t like her haircut, but she’s grateful to be here to complain about. She’s able to play outside with her three boys and enjoyed our block party on the 4th of July. She’ll be returning to work as scheduled next week. 
    The gift box included three boxes of Mike and Ike candy, two sleeves of Peeps, two Peeps Pops and a Peeps Plush. She and her family loved it!
    Peeps would like to send you a Gift box of your choice! Choose one for the expecting parents. Send one to someone celebrating a Birthday or Special Occasion. Pick a friend who needs a little cheering up, to say Thank You, or to a child who is going through a tough week. There’s also one for your sports fan, your best friend, or just because it’s Tuesday and Peeps are your favorite treat. 
    I also have THREE boxes full of Bubble Gum and Lemonade Peeps with a box of Lemonade Mike & Ikes.

    Good Luck and enjoy Peeps all year round!
    All through the month of August, use the discount code 2013PSB for a 20% saving when you purchase from

    add recipe small

    Peeps Party Cake and Cookies

    recipe image

    by Karyn Granrud
    Prep Time: 45 minutes
    Cook Time: 20 minutes


      For the Cake and Cupcakes

      For the Buttercream Frosting

      • 3 sticks Butter
      • 1/4 C Shortening
      • 2 pounds Powdered Sugar
      • 3-5 tablespoons Milk
      • 1 teaspoon Lemon Extract (or vanilla extract)
      • Pink and Yellow Food Coloring – I used Neon

      For the Cookies

      • 1 Pink Lemonade Sugar Cookie bag mix, plus butter and egg as required
      • 4 boxes Lemonade Peeps
      • Paper Straws or 12 inch lollipop sticks
      Make Cake Mix according to directions. Add 1/3 of the batter to a prepared 6 inch cake pan. Add 1/3 of batter to a second 6 inch cake pan and use the remaining 1/3 to make some cupcakes. Bake as directed.
      Make Cookie Mix according to instructions. Measure out batter in a two tablespoon cookie scoop and place on a parchment lined cookie sheet. Place a straw or lollipop stick under the dough ball and flatten to 1/2 inch thickness. Bake as directed.
      Make Buttercream frosting in a mixer with a paddle attachment. Cream Butter and Shortening and add sugar milk and lemon extract. Add more sugar/milk as needed to achieve desired frosting thickness. Remove half for the cookies. Tint half pink for the cake.
      Frost the cake and decorate with the Bubble Gum and Lemonade Peeps in an alternating pattern. Use a dab of frosting to help adhere the Peep if necessary. Place the cake into the fridge.
      Prepare piping bag fitted with an open star tip. Drip Pink and Yellow food coloring down 4 sides of the bag then add in the frosting. Some food coloring will come out the tip, prepare it over the sink. Decorate the cookies and place a Lemonade Peeps on top. Frost your cupcakes, too.
      Just before serving, stand three cookies up in the cake.

      Pint Sized Baker Logo
      I link up at THESE GREAT parties!

      Images, text and all other content Copyrighted©Karyn Granrud, Susanne Queck and Wunderlander Verlag LLC, or ©Pro Stock Media via Unlicensed republishing permitted. As an Amazon affiliate, we earn on qualified purchases.

      Susan Queck

      Susan Queck

      I'm Suzy, the baker and dessert maker behind this blog. Baking is my lifelong passion, where I find the magic in transforming basic ingredients into delectable works of art. Join me in my sweet journey of culinary exploration and celebration! More about me.