Skip to Content

Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles

Cakesicles filled with caramel and chocolate cake and decorated up for Halloween! These are easier than you think to make!

16 Caramel and Chocolate filled Cakesicles all decorated for Halloween!

This post and recipe was created for #HalloweenTreatsWeek! I was sent samples by some of the sponsor companies but as always opinions are 100% mine. 

Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles

Boo!! It’s time to get spooky around here. Okay… not really… but maybe just a little bit with these fun Halloween cakesicles stuffed with caramel and chocolate cake! Oh yeah!! If you love serving cake pops at parties, then you should give cakesicles a try. 

I think that they are a bit easier to make if you have trouble with the cake falling off the stick when your dip your pops into the candy coating. There’s no dipping with cakesicles. 

Orange Halloween Cakesickles on a black platter with skeleton hands and spiders.

However, like anything else, it does take practice and you’ll have a few that really bomb, but just stick with it. 

I’d like to thank Litehouse for the caramel that I used in these cakesicles, Wilton for all the fun cupcake topper candies, and Sweets & Treats for the black sprinkles that were used to make these Spook-tacular Halloween Cakesicles.

White Cakescikles decorated for Halloween on a wooden board.

What is a Cakesicle?

A Cakesicle is a combination of two greats treats – cake pops and popsicles. As you can see from the shape, these look like mini popsicles thanks to the mini moldmini mold. And then they are stuffed with cake pop dough – the cake and frosting mixture that’s used to make cake pops. 

Some people have used marshmallow filling, RKT filling, and other various sweets. 

These have a bit of caramel and cake in the centers for an extra gooey treat!

What do I need for Cakesicles?

To make cakesicles you’ll need the following supplies:

  1. Mini Popsicle Mold
  2. Mini Popsicle Sticks
  3. Halloween Sprinkles
  4. Cupcake Topper Candies
  5. Candy Eyeballs
  6. Candy Melts (black, orange, white)
White ghost candies on black cakesickles with black sprinkles.

Making a Cast

The easiest way to make cakesicles is to start with a cast – lining the mold with the candy coating and allowing it to dry. There a learning curve to figuring out how much candy coating to add to the mold.

Too much and there isn’t enough room for the filling – too thin and there’s holes in the shell and your filling will come out.

So, be sure that the face and the sides are are covered. Doing two thin coats is a good idea. 

I've got my EYE on you! Eyeball candies decorate fun black and white cakesickles on an orange cake platter.

Fill it up

Once the shell is hard, add some caramel to the centers then top it off with a thin, premolded piece of cake pop dough. If you are not going to add the caramel, you can press the cake pop dough into the mold making a more secure fit. 

Then cover the back with a bit more candy coating. Give the mold some good taps against the counter top to do your best to get any air bubbles out.

Scrape off any excess coating and try to clean the mold as much as possible.

8 Halloween Cakesickles on a black platter.

Removing your Cakesicles

Pop your cakesicles into the freezer for 5 minutes to get your candy to completely harden. If the candy is hard, then popping the cakesickles out of the silicone is pretty easy. Now you’re ready for the fun part of decorating them! 

This is where all you can get as creative as you like. Add stripes, sprinkles, candies – whatever you want to do goes! 

There’s no wrong way to decorate the cakesicles, so have fun with them.

An orange cakesickle with black sprinkles and ghost candies.

How did you make the black and white ones?

The “mummy eyeball” cakesicles were actually an after thought. Remember how I mentioned to experiment and practice earlier? Well these are a result of me doing just that. 

I had a little white candy coating still in a piping bag so I just added a few drizzles to the mold. Popped it into the freezer for a few minutes and then carefully added the black coating. These have a bit of a thicker shell because I couldn’t get in there with my spatchula, so I just tapped and wiggled the mold around to coat the insides.

I was super thrilled when I pulled them out of the mold. They looked amazing and the eyeball candies just make them look spookier! 

What do you think?

Cakesickles filled with caramel and chocolate cake and decorated up for Halloween! These are easier than you think to make!

So, what do you think? Can you make these? I know that you can! There’s so many awesome cakesicles on Instagram that you can check for inspiration. 

And I’ve given you several fun ways to decorate your Halloween Cakesicles.

White ghost candies on black cakesickles with black sprinkles.

#HalloweenTreatsWeek – 2019

Check out the amazing #HalloweenTreatsWeek recipes from our bloggers today!

These boo-tiful Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles are going to bring down the house at your spooktacular Halloween party!

Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles

16 Caramel and Chocolate filled Cakesicles all decorated for Halloween!

These boo-tiful Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles are going to bring down the house at your spooktacular Halloween party!

Prep Time 1 hour 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 30 minutes

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Melt your candy melts in microwave safe containers. Heat for 1 minute at 70% power - stir - 30 seconds at 70% power - stir. Candy melts should be melted and smooth.
  2. Pour some candy coating into your mini popsicle mold. Use a spoon or small spatula to coat the sides of the mold. Insert the popsicle sticks while the candy is still wet. Place the mold into the freezer for 5 minutes.
  3. Transfer the Litehouse caramel to a baggie. Snip off the corner.
  4. Remove the molds from the freezer and pipe a bit of caramel into each cavity. Top it with a small, preshaped piece of cake pop dough.
  5. Cover the edges of the cakesicle with candy coating and tap on the counter to get any air bubbles out. Cover the back completely with candy coating and scrape off any excess. Return to the freezer for 5 minutes.
  6. Remove the hard cakesickles from the mold and repeat the process to make as many cakesicles as you need.
  7. Use some candy to decorate the cakesicles. Pip on lines to add sprinkles, or use a toothpick to add smaller items. Allow to completely dry. Four Easy Halloween Cakesicles to inspire you to make some

Notes

For 16 cakesicles with the caramel, you can use 1/4 of a sheet cake with 1 tablespoon of frosting to make your cake pop dough. Smoosh together in a gallon baggie until it's at a PlaDoh like consistency.

If you are omitting the caramel, you'll want more cake pop dough.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

8

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 150

Haunted House Cupcake Tower
ā† Read Last Post
Three layer naked cake recipe is finished. Topped with delicious frosting between the layers of this naked cake recipe.
Banana Caramel Layer Cake +Video
Read Next Post ā†’

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes with Pumpkin Frosting and Spooky Sprinkles #HalloweenTreatsWeek - Nancie's Table

Monday 14th of September 2020

[…] Halloween Chocolate and Caramel Cakesicles from Pint Sized Baker […]

Christie

Saturday 16th of November 2019

Yours look so much better than mine did. I"ll have to keep trying. They look perfectly delicious.

Day of the Dead Margaritas (Blood Orange Hibiscus) #HalloweenTreatsWeek | The Spiffy Cookie

Thursday 31st of October 2019

[…] Halloween Cakesickles from Pint Sized Baker […]

Jaida ~ Sweet Beginnings

Wednesday 23rd of October 2019

These are absolutely precious! I might just make some to take to my daughter's daycare for Halloween!

Loaded Bat Bark #HalloweenTreatsWeek - Who Needs A Cape?

Saturday 19th of October 2019

[…] Halloween Cakesickles from Pint Sized Baker […]

Skip to Recipe